ArXiv paper summary: An Upcoming Generation of Adaptive Secondary Mirrors
Here’s a quick-read summary of two papers about an astronomical adaptive optics technology in development from UC Santa Cruz
“Developing Adaptive Secondary Mirror Concepts for the APF and W.M. Keck Observatory Based on HVR Technology” (Hinz et al 2020)
“Performance of Large-Format Deformable Mirrors Constructed with Hybrid Variable Reluctance Actuators II: Initial Lab Results from FLASH” (Bowens-Rubin et al 2021)
Intro
Advanced ground based telescopes use adaptive optics (AO) to correct the blurs created by the atmospheric turbulence when the light travels through the air down to the telescope. Without adaptive optics correction, large telescopes would be limited to resolving objects with a separation closer to the atmospheric seeing at the site rather than the diffraction limit of the telescope. An ideal adaptive optics system can let its telescope on the ground take pictures of objects as if it were imaging in space.
In an adaptive optics system, the light bounces off of a deformable mirror, which physically changes shape to correct the wavefront. In a traditional AO system, the deformable mirror is added as a set of extra optical components post focal plane. For example, the Keck NIRC2 AO system adds 7 extra reflections to the optical path and accounts for approximately one-half of the thermal background noise present in mid-IR images at 4.7microns . Although small, this thermal noise and throughput loss can prove detrimental to sensitive photon-limited science, especially in the infrared.
Replacing the static secondary mirror with an adaptive secondary mirror (ASM) provides a method to integrate the AO system directly into the telescope, streamlining the optical path and reducing the thermal background and throughput loss. An adaptive secondary mirror also provides a way to do widefield adaptive optics correction. Unlike the little deformable mirrors from Boston Micromachines that work because of magic material science, the adaptive secondary mirrors are built on a “large-format” scale that use a set of actuators that push and pull on a millimeter-thick glass facesheet.
Observatories like the MMT, LBT, and VLT have demonstrated the science benefits of using an adaptive secondary mirror. However, the accessibility of the current generation of ASMs is limited because of the high power demands and heat generation of their voice-coil style actuators. Over the past five years, The Netherlands Organization (TNO) has developed a new style of hybrid variable-reluctance actuator that is ~75 times more power efficient than the older voice-coil actuator technology. While the HVR actuator technology is promising, it is still in the early stages of development and has yet to be demonstrated on-sky.
The two papers released on arXiv last week outline three different deformable mirrors built or in the concept stage that will be made with the hybrid-reluctance variable actuator technology.
The FLASH lab prototype
In January of 2021, I began evaluating the performance of the 19-actuator FLASH deformable mirror (the “First Lab for adaptive optics Adaptive Secondary Holophote”). The FLASH was designed as a prototyping device for the UH2.2m adaptive secondary mirror, which will be commissioned during 2022 on the University of Hawaii Telescope on Maunakea. The FLASH was the first large format deformable mirror commissioned by the UCSC Lab for Adaptive Optics and the first prototype from TNO to have space for a set of integrated capacitive sensors.
We used a Zygo Interferometer to to understand a holistic view of the mirror shape and the integrated capacitive sensors to passively provide dynamic time response information. The paper “Performance of Large-Format Deformable Mirrors Constructed with Hybrid Variable Reluctance Actuators II: Initial Lab Results from FLASH” (Bowens-Rubin et al 2021) summarizes the procedures we used to do this performance testing. Our results verify that the predicted and measured performance of the TNO deformable mirrors is consistent, including the quoted high actuator linearity (>95%) and low hysteresis (<2%) in a working range of ±7 microns.
Future lab testing will be run to verify the performance under changing temperature and gravity conditions. FLASH will also be used to test the electronic system for the UH2.2m ASM.
An Adaptive Secondary Mirror for the UC Lick Automated Planet Finder
The UC Lick Automated Planet Finder telescope is a 2.4m in diameter robotic telescope near San Jose CA that is dedicated to searching for exoplanets using the radial velocity method. Every night (that’s not cloudy), the APF automatically opens its dome and slews across the sky to take precision spectroscopy measurements of stars that could host exoplanet systems. These RV measurements are critical for discovering new planets, constraining an exoplanet’s orbital properties, and measuring an exoplanet’s masses. However, as we enter the era of TESS and JWST, the exoplanet community is facing a shortage in instrumentation that can carry out these critical radial velocity measurements.
By adding an adaptive optics system to the APF, we could stabilize the star’s PSF and better concentrate the light entering the spectrograph slit. Our modeling shows that we could nearly double the photons collected per second (from an efficiency of ~23% to 48%). This would be an efficiency gain like you added a whole second telescope! Either more targets could be covered per night and/or the APF could view dimmer targets and alleviate some of the pressure put on RV instruments operating at larger telescopes. An ASM also offers a unique solution to upgrading the APF without disturbing the internals of in the spectrograph and disrupting the long-running RV baselines.
The proposed ASM is 37cm in diameter and will have approximately 60 actuators. It would be paired with a Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensor, replacing the current tip/tilt system in the APF.
The project is currently seeking funding. If built, it would be the first pairing of an adaptive secondary mirror and a radial velocity instrument and become a pathfinder for similar pairings at large observatories. More technical information can be found in “Developing Adaptive Secondary Mirror Concepts for the APF and W.M. Keck Observatory Based on HVR Technology” (Hinz et al 2020)
Speaking of larger observatories… let’s talk about Keck!
An Adaptive Secondary Mirror for the W. M. Keck Observatory
The W.M. Keck Observatory is located on Maunakea, Hawaii and has two 10m telescopes that together house ten science instruments. An ASM at Keck could provide ground layer AO correction and improved thermal infrared observations for multiple science instruments.
The current Keck instruments that could benefit from an ASM are:
- MOSFIRE would benefit from ground layer AO correction with some minimal modifications.
- LRIS could benefit from ground layer AO correction if flexure compensation is added.
- DEIMOS could benefit from GLAO if an atmospheric dispersion compensator were added.
- OSIRIS and NIRC2 currently use the AO bench. They could take advantage of an AO system with fewer optics and a higher actuator count if much of the functionality of the current AO bench (wavefront sensor, image rotator, etc) were rebuilt to utilize the ASM.
- KCWI may benefit from GLAO.
- HIRES may benefit from increased PSF stability, similar to the case for the APF telescope.
The future Keck instruments that would benefit from an ASM are:
- SCALES is an infrared field spectrograph (set to work into the mid-IR at 5 microns). It would take advantage of the lower thermal background.
- FOBOS is a wide-field fiber fed spectrograph that could conduct science significantly more efficiently if fed with a GLAO correction. It may be the instrument that would most benefit from the addition of GLAO.
- LRIS2, an upgrade of LRIS, would be more equipped than its predecessor to handle the modifications needed to use the ASM. Like LRIS, it would benefit from GLAO correction.
- IGNIS is an infrared instrument (out to 2 microns) that would benefit from improved thermal background.
The Keck ASM concepts consider 1000–4000 actuators packed into a secondary mirror that is 1.4m in diameter (projected spacing on the primary between ~175–350 mm). A design with a 4000 actuator count, while more expensive, would benefit visible light AO correction which will be in demand from ground-based facilities when Hubble retires. The ASM would be housed in a dedicated existing top-end module which can be swapped easily during day-time operations. The Keck ASM constructed with hybrid variable reluctance actuators would not require a dedicated cooling system, unlike the current generation of ASMs at other facilities.
A concept study for the Keck ASM was funded in 2020 and the project received Phase A proposal funding in 2021. More technical information can be found in “Developing Adaptive Secondary Mirror Concepts for the APF and W.M. Keck Observatory Based on HVR Technology” (Hinz et al 2020) or in the Keck White Paper/Phase A proposal.
